206/PDT.SUS-PHI/2015/PN.BDG
Putusan PN BANDUNG Nomor 206/PDT.SUS-PHI/2015/PN.BDG
Plaintiffs / Applicants (1)
Filing or appealing side
Plaintiff (1)
Defendants / Respondents (1)
Responding side
Defendant (1)
Jl Prof. Satrio Nomor 25, Karet Kuningan, Setiabudi
Also in 100 other cases
DALAM KONPENSI DALAM EKSEPSI Menolak Eksepsi Tergugat untuk seluruhnya; DALAM POKOK PERKARA 1. Mengabulkan gugatan para Penggugat untuk sebagian; 2. Menghukum Tergugat membayar Kenaikan upah para Penggugat dengan perincian kekurangan upah tahun 2013 seluruhnya sebesar Rp. 204.864.019,- (dua ratus empat juta delapan ratus enam puluh empat juta sembilan belas rupiah ), tahun 2014 seluruhnya sebesar Rp. 225.232.822,- (dua ratus dua puluh lima juta dua ratus tiga puluh dua ribu delapan ratus dua puluh dua rupiah) dan tahun 2015 seluruhnya sebesar Rp. 241.712.466,- (dua ratus empat puluh satu juta tujuh ratus dua belas ribu empat ratus enam puluh enam ribu rupiah) seluruhnya selama 3 (tiga) tahun berjumlah Rp. 671.809.307,- (enam ratus tujuh puluh satu juta delapan ratus sembilan ribu tiga ratus tujuh rupiah) dengan perhitungan sebagai berikut; Kenaikan Gaji Tahun 2013 sebesar 10 % terdapat kekurangan Upah selama 1 (satu) tahun NO N ama Gaji Kenaikan Jumlah Kekurangan Kekurangan Tahun tahun 2013 Gaji selama 2013 10% setiap bulan 12 bln th 2013 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 1 Rukmana 3,800,247 380,025 4,180,272 380,025 4,560,296 2 Entur 4,318,008 431,801 4,749,809 431,801 5,181,610 3 Timin 4,140,750 414,075 4,554,825 414,075 4,968,900 4 Nantiar 4,781,798 478,180 5,259,978 478,180 5,738,158 5 Saepudin 4,206,495 420,650 4,627,145 420,650 5,047,794 6 Uus Rusmana 4,485,008 448,501 4,933,509 448,501 5,382,010 7 Sape'i 3,557,370 355,737 3,913,107 355,737 4,268,844 8 Dasep Ruslan 4,279,158 427,916 4,707,074 427,916 5,134,990 9 Dede Supriatna 3,646,191 364,619 4,010,810 364,619 4,375,429 10 Aten Ruhiyat 3,976,699 397,670 4,374,369 397,670 4,772,039 11 Ngadimun 4,141,145 414,115 4,555,260 414,115 4,969,374 12 Dede Wawan 4,055,263 405,526 4,460,789 405,526 4,866,316 13 Saepul Iman 3,639,750 363,975 4,003,725 363,975 4,367,700 14 Jaja Muhamad 4,160,469 416,047 4,576,516 416,047 4,992,563 15 Dadang Sudrajat 3,705,961 370,596 4,076,557 370,596 4,447,153 16 Enda Purnama 3,445,992 344,599 3,790,591 344,599 4,135,190 17 Wahyu Diana 3,067,276 306,728 3,374,004 306,728 3,680,731 18 Asep Permana 3,393,013 339,301 3,732,314 339,301 4,071,616 19 Yayan Peri Sopyan 3,365,403 336,540 3,701,943 336,540 4,038,484 20 Agus Hamdan 3,240,473 324,047 3,564,520 324,047 3,888,568 21 Paino 3,092,354 309,235 3,401,589 309,235 3,710,825 22 Eman Suherman 3,520,790 352,079 3,872,869 352,079 4,224,948 23 Sumini 3,317,087 331,709 3,648,796 331,709 3,980,504 24 Wahyuningsih 3,250,099 325,010 3,575,109 325,010 3,900,119 25 Sukarni 3,004,707 300,471 3,305,178 300,471 3,605,648 26 Budi Janto 3,381,180 338,118 3,719,298 338,118 4,057,416 27 Edi Junaedi 3,350,941 335,094 3,686,035 335,094 4,021,129 28 Atang Setiawan 3,337,311 333,731 3,671,042 333,731 4,004,773 29 Suryati 3,306,238 330,624 3,636,862 330,624 3,967,486 30 Syaiful Anwar 3,336,478 333,648 3,670,126 333,648 4,003,774 31 Deddy Wartono 3,300,273 330,027 3,630,300 330,027 3,960,328 32 Jimy Somantry Khan 3,110,832 311,083 3,421,915 311,083 3,732,998 33 Rahmat Rahayu 3,293,398 329,340 3,622,738 329,340 3,952,078 34 Hasan Basri 3,353,754 335,375 3,689,129 335,375 4,024,505 35 Iman Syarial Lubis 5,675,000 567,500 6,242,500 567,500 6,810,000 36 Yadi Kardiyat 3,952,914 395,291 4,348,205 395,291 4,743,497 37 Sugiyanto 3,021,891 302,189 3,324,080 302,189 3,626,269 38 Casmita 3,074,149 307,415 3,381,564 307,415 3,688,979 39 Mustahal Prakoso 3,360,282 336,028 3,696,310 336,028 4,032,338 40 Dudi Iskandar 2,875,583 287,558 3,163,141 287,558 3,450,700 41 Erwin Suherman 2,988,834 298,883 3,287,717 298,883 3,586,601 42 Jakaria 3,146,546 314,655 3,461,201 314,655 3,775,855 43 Agus Salim Arsyad 3,137,750 313,775 3,451,525 313,775 3,765,300 44 Uce Abubakar 2,710,235 271,024 2,981,259 271,024 3,252,282 45 Masrizal 3,728,774 372,877 4,101,651 372,877 4,474,529 46 Darsan 3,255,248 325,525 3,580,773 325,525 3,906,298 47 Tugiyanto 3,299,473 329,947 3,629,420 329,947 3,959,368 48 Dody Setiawan 3,131,426 313,143 3,444,569 313,143 3,757,711 17,072,002 204,864,019 Kenaikan gaji Tahun 2014 sebesar 10 % terdapat kekurangan Upah selama 1 (satu) tahun No N ama Kenaikan Gaji yg seha Kekurangan Kekurangan Gaji tahun 2014 rusnya thn gajiTahun selama tahun 2014 10% 2014 setiap bulan 12 bln th 2014 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 1 Rukmana 4,180,272 418,027 4,598,299 418,027 5,016,326 2 Entur 4,749,809 474,981 5,224,790 474,981 5,699,771 3 Timin 4,554,825 455,483 5,010,308 455,483 5,465,790 4 Nantiar 5,259,978 525,998 5,785,976 525,998 6,311,974 5 Saepudin 4,627,145 462,715 5,089,860 462,715 5,552,574 6 Uus Rusmana 4,933,509 493,351 5,426,860 493,351 5,920,211 7 Sape'i 3,913,107 391,311 4,304,418 391,311 4,695,728 8 Dasep Ruslan 4,707,074 470,707 5,177,781 470,707 5,648,489 9 Dede Supriatna 4,010,810 401,081 4,411,891 401,081 4,812,972 10 Aten Ruhiyat 4,374,369 437,437 4,811,806 437,437 5,249,243 11 Ngadimun 4,555,260 455,526 5,010,786 455,526 5,466,312 12 Dede Wawan 4,460,789 446,079 4,906,868 446,079 5,352,947 13 Saepul Iman 4,003,725 400,373 4,404,098 400,373 4,804,470 14 Jaja Muhamad 4,578,516 457,852 5,036,368 457,852 5,494,219 15 Dadang Sudrajat 4,076,557 407,656 4,484,213 407,656 4,891,868 16 Enda Purnama 3,790,591 379,059 4,169,650 379,059 4,548,709 17 Wahyu Diana 3,374,004 337,400 3,711,404 337,400 4,048,805 18 Asep Permana 3,732,314 373,231 4,105,545 373,231 4,478,777 19 Yayan Peri Sopyan 3,701,943 370,194 4,072,137 370,194 4,442,332 20 Agus Hamdan 3,564,520 356,452 3,920,972 356,452 4,277,424 21 Paino 3,401,589 340,159 3,741,748 340,159 4,081,907 22 Eman Suherman 3,872,869 387,287 4,260,156 387,287 4,647,443 23 Sumini 3,648,796 364,880 4,013,676 364,880 4,378,555 24 Wahyuningsih 3,575,109 357,511 3,932,620 357,511 4,290,131 25 Sukarni 3,305,178 330,518 3,635,696 330,518 3,966,214 26 Budi Janto 3,719,298 371,930 4,091,228 371,930 4,463,158 27 Edi Junaedi 3,686,035 368,604 4,054,639 368,604 4,423,242 28 Atang Setiawan 3,671,042 367,104 4,038,146 367,104 4,405,250 29 Suryati 3,636,862 363,686 4,000,548 363,686 4,364,234 30 Syaiful Anwar 3,670,126 367,013 4,037,139 367,013 4,404,151 31 Deddy Wartono 3,630,300 363,030 3,993,330 363,030 4,356,360 32 Jimy Somantry Khan 3,421,915 342,192 3,764,107 342,192 4,106,298 33 Rahmat Rahayu 3,622,738 362,274 3,985,012 362,274 4,347,286 34 Hasan Basri 3,689,129 368,913 4,058,042 368,913 4,426,955 35 Iman Syarial Lubis 6,242,500 624,250 6,866,750 624,250 7,491,000 36 Yadi Kardiyat 4,248,205 424,821 4,673,026 424,821 5,097,846 37 Sugiyanto 3,324,080 332,408 3,656,488 332,408 3,988,896 38 Casmita 3,381,564 338,156 3,719,720 338,156 4,057,877 39 Mustahal Prakoso 3,696,310 369,631 4,065,941 369,631 4,435,572 40 Dudi Iskandar 3,163,141 316,314 3,479,455 316,314 3,795,769 41 Erwin Suherman 3,287,717 328,772 3,616,489 328,772 3,945,260 42 Jakaria 3,461,201 346,120 3,807,321 346,120 4,153,441 43 Agus Salim Arsyad 3,451,525 345,153 3,796,678 345,153 4,141,830 44 Uce Abubakar 2,981,259 298,126 3,279,385 298,126 3,577,511 45 Masrizal 4,101,651 410,165 4,511,816 410,165 4,921,981 46 Darsan 3,580,773 358,077 3,938,850 358,077 4,296,928 47 Tugiyanto 3,629,420 362,942 3,992,362 362,942 4,355,304 48 Dody Setiawan 3,444,569 344,457 3,789,026 344,457 4,133,483 18,769,402 225,232,822 Kenaikan gaji tahun 2015 sebesar 10 % terdapat kekurangan Upah selama 1 (satu) tahun No N ama Kenaikan Gaji yg seha Kekurangan Kekurangan gaji tahun 2015 rusnya thn Gaji selama tahun 2015 10% 2015 setiap bulan 12 bln th 2015 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 1 Rukmana 4,598,299 459,830 5,058,129 459,830 5,517,959 2 Entur 5,224,790 522,479 5,747,269 522,479 6,269,748 3 Timin 5,010,308 501,031 5,511,339 501,031 6,012,370 4 Nantiar 5,785,975 578,598 6,364,573 578,598 6,943,170 5 Saepudin 5,089,860 508,986 5,598,846 508,986 6,107,832 6 Uus Rusmana 5,426,860 542,686 5,969,546 542,686 6,512,232 7 Sape'i 4,304,418 430,442 4,734,860 430,442 5,165,302 8 Dasep Ruslan 5,177,781 517,778 5,695,559 517,778 6,213,337 9 Dede Supriatna 4,411,891 441,189 4,853,080 441,189 5,294,269 10 Aten Ruhiyat 4,811,806 481,181 5,292,987 481,181 5,774,167 11 Ngadimun 5,010,786 501,079 5,511,865 501,079 6,012,943 12 Dede Wawan 4,906,868 490,687 5,397,555 490,687 5,888,242 13 Saepul Iman 4,404,098 440,410 4,844,508 440,410 5,284,918 14 Jaja Muhamad 5,036,368 503,637 5,540,005 503,637 6,043,642 15 Dadang Sudrajat 4,484,213 448,421 4,932,634 448,421 5,381,056 16 Enda Purnama 4,169,650 416,965 4,586,615 416,965 5,003,580 17 Wahyu Diana 3,711,404 371,140 4,082,544 371,140 4,453,685 18 Asep Permana 4,105,545 410,555 4,516,100 410,555 4,926,654 19 Yayan Peri Sopyan 4,072,137 407,214 4,479,351 407,214 4,886,564 20 Agus Hamdan 3,920,972 392,097 4,313,069 392,097 4,705,166 21 Paino 3,741,748 374,175 4,115,923 374,175 4,490,098 22 Eman Suherman 4,260,156 426,016 4,686,172 426,016 5,112,187 23 Sumini 4,013,676 401,368 4,415,044 401,368 4,816,411 24 Wahyuningsih 3,932,620 393,262 4,325,882 393,262 4,719,144 25 Sukarni 3,635,696 363,570 3,999,266 363,570 4,362,835 26 Budi Janto 4,091,228 409,123 4,500,351 409,123 4,909,474 27 Edi Junaedi 4,054,639 405,464 4,460,103 405,464 4,865,567 28 Atang Setiawan 4,038,146 403,815 4,441,961 403,815 4,845,775 29 Suryati 4,000,548 400,055 4,400,603 400,055 4,800,658 30 Syaiful Anwar 4,037,139 403,714 4,440,853 403,714 4,844,567 31 Deddy Wartono 3,993,330 399,333 4,392,663 399,333 4,791,996 32 Jimy Somantry Khan 3,764,107 376,411 4,140,518 376,411 4,516,928 33 Rahmat Rahayu 3,985,012 398,501 4,383,513 398,501 4,782,014 34 Hasan Basri 4,058,042 405,804 4,463,846 405,804 4,869,650 35 Iman Syarial Lubis 6,866,750 686,675 7,553,425 686,675 8,240,100 36 Yadi Kardiyat 4,673,026 467,303 5,140,329 467,303 5,607,631 37 Sugiyanto 3,656,488 365,649 4,022,137 365,649 4,387,786 38 Casmita 3,719,720 371,972 4,091,692 371,972 4,463,664 39 Mustahal Prakoso 4,065,941 406,594 4,472,535 406,594 4,879,129 40 Dudi Iskandar 3,479,455 347,946 3,827,401 347,946 4,175,346 41 Erwin Suherman 3,616,489 361,649 3,978,138 361,649 4,339,787 42 Jakaria 3,807,321 380,732 4,188,053 380,732 4,568,785 43 Agus Salim Arsyad 3,796,678 379,668 4,176,346 379,668 4,556,014 44 Uce Abubakar 3,279,385 327,939 3,607,324 327,939 3,935,262 45 Masrizal 4,511,816 451,182 4,962,998 451,182 5,414,179 46 Darsan 3,938,850 393,885 4,332,735 393,885 4,726,620 47 Tugiyanto 3,992,362 399,236 4,391,598 399,236 4,790,834 48 Dody Setiawan 3,789,026 378,903 4,167,929 378,903 4,546,831 20,646,342 247,756,108 3. Menolak gugatan para Penggugat selain dan selebihnya; DALAM REKONPENSI Menolak gugatan Penggugat Rekonpensi untuk seluruhnya; DALAM KOPENSI DAN REKONPENSI Membebankan biaya perkara kepada Tergugat Konpensi/ Penggugat Rekonpensi Negara sebesar Rp. 531.000,- (lima ratus tiga puluh satu ribu rupiah);