1357 K/Pdt.Sus-PHI/2021
Putusan MAHKAMAH AGUNG Nomor 1357 K/Pdt.Sus-PHI/2021
Plaintiffs / Applicants (1)
Filing or appealing side
Applicant (1)
Defendants / Respondents (1)
Responding side
Respondent (1)
Jl. Paus Blok A/89 D-E
Also in 4 other cases
1. Menolak permohonan kasasi dari Pemohon Kasasi 1. ABDUL HARIS, 2. ABDULLOH, 3. ABDULOH SAPI'I, 4. AHAD NURALI, 5. AKHMAD ROZIKIN, 6. ANDI HERMAWAN, 7. ANTOK PRANA WIANJAYA, 8. ARIPUL IMAM, 9. ASEP SAEPUL, 10. AZIZ FIRMAN FITRIYANTO, 11. CAHYA WIDADA, 12. DADI ISKANDAR, 13. DAVIT VAN HOTEN, 14. DEDE ISKANDAR, 15. DILSI SAPUTRA, 16. FAHRIZAL MAURAKSA, 17. FARIZ MIFTAHUL HUDA, 18. FEBRI ARDIANSYAH, 19. HARI ANGGARA, 20. HASANUDIN, 21. JULIUS HENRY LUMBAN TOBING, 22. KHOIRUL MUNIR, 23. KIKI IRAWAN, 24. KUKUH INSAF FIDI SETYO NUGROHO, 25. LUQMAN SUBEKTI, 26. M. ASRI SUPRIANA, 27. MARZUKI, MUKSON, 28. NAKIM, 29. NANA SUGIANA, 30. NANANG SUTRISNA, 31. NAYAT BIN NYIMIN, 33. NOVI ANDRIANTO, 34. NURDIN, 35. PAHRIZAL MAWARDI, 36. PRAYOGA, 37. RUSMAN, 38. SARMAN, 39. SUGENG BUWONO, 40. SYAHRIZAL, 41. TATA ATMAJA, 42. TOMMY PEBRIYANTO, 43. TUYAR, 44. WAHAB KURNIAWAN SAPUTRA, 45. WAHYUDIN, 46. YAYAN WINASIS, 47. ZAENAL, 48. ZANUR SAPUTRO, tersebut; 2. Memperbaiki amar Putusan Pengadilan Hubungan Industrial pada Pengadilan Negeri Bandung Nomor 47/Pdt.Sus.PHI/2021/PN Bdg., tanggal 9 Juni 2021 sehingga amar selengkapnya sebagai berikut: Dalam Konvensi: 1. Mengabulkan gugatan Para Penggugat Konvensi untuk sebagian; 2. Menyatakan hubungan kerja antara Para Penggugat dengan Tergugat sebagai perjanjian kerja waktu tidak tertentu, sejak tidak adanya perpanjangan/pembaharuan perjanjian kerja waktu tertentu; 3. Menyatakan hubungan kerja Para Penggugat dengan Tergugat putus sejak 13 Juli 2020 dikualifikasikan mengundurkan diri; 4. Menghukum Tergugat untuk membayar tunai dan sekaligus uang pesangon, uang penghargaan masa kerja, dan uang penggantian hak kepada Para Penggugat sebesar Rp1.013.407.526,00 (satu miliar tiga belas juta empat ratus tujuh ribu lima ratus dua puluh enam rupiah) dengan rincian: No. Nama Gaji (Rp) Mulai Kerja PHK Masa Kerja Pesangon (Rp) (Bulan Upah) Penghargaan UPMK= Bulan Upah X Gaji (Rp.) Jumlah (Rp) UPH= 15% X Jumlah (Rp) Total= Jumlah + UPH (Rp) 1 Abdul Haris 4.589.708 29/06/2019 13/07/2020 1 9.179.416 0 - 9.179.416 1.376.912 10.556.328 2 Abdulloh 4.589.708 27/05/2019 13/07/2020 1 9.179.416 0 - 9.179.416 1.376.912 10.556.328 3 Abduloh Sapi'i 4.589.708 01/05/2019 13/07/2020 1 9.179.416 0 - 9.179.416 1.376.912 10.556.328 4 Ahad Nurali 4.589.708 27/04/2019 13/07/2020 1 9.179.416 0 - 9.179.416 1.376.912 10.556.328 5 Akhmad Rozikin 4.589.708 22/05/2017 13/07/2020 3 18.358.832 2 9.179.416 27.538.248 4.130.737 31.668.985 6 Andi Hermawan 4.589.708 29/06/2019 13/07/2020 1 9.179.416 0 - 9.179.416 1.376.912 10.556.328 7 Antok Prana Wianjaya 4.589.708 18/11/2017 13/07/2020 2 13.769.124 0 - 13.769.124 2.065.369 15.834.493 8 Aripul Imam 4.589.708 18/11/2017 13/07/2020 2 13.769.124 0 - 13.769.124 2.065.369 15.834.493 9 Asep Saepul 4.589.708 01/05/2019 13/07/2020 1 9.179.416 0 - 9.179.416 1.376.912 10.556.328 10 Aziz Firman Fitriyanto 4.589.708 18/11/2017 13/07/2020 2 13.769.124 0 - 13.769.124 2.065.369 15.834.493 11 Cahya Widada 4.589.708 30/06/2012 13/07/2020 8 41.307.372 3 13.769.124 55.076.496 8.261.474 63.337.970 12 Dadi Iskandar 4.589.708 01/05/2019 13/07/2020 1 9.179.416 0 - 9.179.416 1.376.912 10.556.328 13 Davit Van Hoten 4.589.708 30/06/2016 13/07/2020 4 22.948.540 2 9.179.416 32.127.956 4.819.193 36.947.149 14 Dede Iskandar 4.589.708 30/06/2019 13/07/2020 1 9.179.416 0 - 9.179.416 1.376.912 10.556.328 15 Dilsi Saputra 4.589.708 01/05/2019 13/07/2020 1 9.179.416 0 - 9.179.416 1.376.912 10.556.328 16 Fahrizal Mauraksa 4.589.708 29/06/2013 13/07/2020 7 36.717.664 3 13.769.124 50.486.788 7.573.018 58.059.806 17 Fariz Miftahul Huda 4.589.708 30/06/2019 13/07/2020 1 9.179.416 0 - 9.179.416 1.376.912 10.556.328 18 Febri Ardiansyah 4.589.708 11/04/2017 13/07/2020 3 18.358.832 2 9.179.416 27.538.248 4.130.737 31.668.985 19 Hari Anggara 4.589.708 22/05/2019 13/07/2020 1 9.179.416 0 - 9.179.416 1.376.912 10.556.328 20 Hasanudin 4.589.708 29/06/2019 13/07/2020 1 9.179.416 0 - 9.179.416 1.376.912 10.556.328 21 Julius Henry Lumban Tobing 4.589.708 05/11/2017 13/07/2020 2 13.769.124 0 - 13.769.124 2.065.369 15.834.493 22 Khoirul Munir 4.589.708 01/07/2017 13/07/2020 3 18.358.832 2 9.179.416 27.538.248 4.130.737 31.668.985 23 Kiki Irawan 4.589.708 29/06/2019 13/07/2020 1 9.179.416 0 - 9.179.416 1.376.912 10.556.328 24 Kukuh Insaf Fidi Setyo Nugroho 4.589.708 01/10/2018 13/07/2020 1 9.179.416 0 - 9.179.416 1.376.912 10.556.328 25 Luqman Subekti 4.589.708 01/06/2019 13/07/2020 1 9.179.416 0 - 9.179.416 1.376.912 10.556.328 26 M. Asri Supriana 4.589.708 29/06/2019 13/07/2020 1 9.179.416 0 - 9.179.416 1.376.912 10.556.328 27 Marzuki 4.589.708 01/07/2017 13/07/2020 3 18.358.832 2 9.179.416 27.538.248 4.130.737 31.668.985 28 Mukson 4.589.708 18/11/2017 13/07/2020 2 13.769.124 0 - 13.769.124 2.065.369 15.834.493 29 Nakim 4.589.708 01/07/2017 13/07/2020 3 18.358.832 2 9.179.416 27.538.248 4.130.737 31.668.985 30 Nana Sugiana 4.589.708 18/11/2017 13/07/2020 2 13.769.124 0 - 13.769.124 2.065.369 15.834.493 31 Nanang Sutrisna 4.589.708 28/06/2019 13/07/2020 1 9.179.416 0 - 9.179.416 1.376.912 10.556.328 32 Nayat bin Nyimin 4.589.708 30/06/2016 13/07/2020 4 22.948.540 2 9.179.416 32.127.956 4.819.193 36.947.149 33 Novi Andrianto 4.589.708 02/10/2017 13/07/2020 2 13.769.124 0 - 13.769.124 2.065.369 15.834.493 34 Nurdin 4.589.708 25/03/2013 13/07/2020 7 36.717.664 3 13.769.124 50.486.788 7.573.018 58.059.806 35 Pahrizal Mawardi 4.589.708 01/07/2017 13/07/2020 3 18.358.832 2 9.179.416 27.538.248 4.130.737 31.668.985 36 Prayoga 4.589.708 28/10/2018 13/07/2020 1 9.179.416 0 - 9.179.416 1.376.912 10.556.328 37 Rusman 4.589.708 28/06/2014 13/07/2020 6 32.127.956 3 13.769.124 45.897.080 6.884.562 52.781.642 38 Sarman 4.589.708 30/11/2018 13/07/2020 1 9.179.416 0 - 9.179.416 1.376.912 10.556.328 39 Sugeng Buwono 4.589.708 29/06/2019 13/07/2020 1 9.179.416 0 - 9.179.416 1.376.912 10.556.328 40 Syahrizal 4.589.708 29/06/2019 13/07/2020 1 9.179.416 0 - 9.179.416 1.376.912 10.556.328 41 Tata Atmaja 4.589.708 29/06/2013 13/07/2020 7 36.717.664 3 13.769.124 50.486.788 7.573.018 58.059.806 42 Tommy Pebriyanto 4.589.708 21/12/2018 13/07/2020 1 9.179.416 0 - 9.179.416 1.376.912 10.556.328 43 Tuyar 4.589.708 29/10/2017 13/07/2020 2 13.769.124 0 - 13.769.124 2.065.369 15.834.493 44 Wahab Kurniawan Saputra 4.589.708 29/06/2019 13/07/2020 1 9.179.416 0 - 9.179.416 1.376.912 10.556.328 45 Wahyudin 4.589.708 30/06/2018 13/07/2020 2 13.769.124 0 - 13.769.124 2.065.369 15.834.493 46 Yayan Winasis 4.589.708 28/06/2014 13/07/2020 6 32.127.956 3 13.769.124 45.897.080 6.884.562 52.781.642 47 Zaenal 4.589.708 05/06/2019 13/07/2020 1 9.179.416 0 - 9.179.416 1.376.912 10.556.328 48 Zanur Saputro 4.589.708 29/06/2019 13/07/2020 1 9.179.416 0 - 9.179.416 1.376.912 10.556.328 220.305.984 725.173.864 156.050.072 881.223.936 132.183.590 1.013.407.526 total Rp1.013.407.526,00 (satu miliar tiga belas juta empat ratus tujuh ribu lima ratus dua puluh enam rupiah) ; 5. Menolak gugatan Para Penggugat Konvensi selain dan selebihnya; Dalam Rekonvensi: - Menolak gugatan Penggugat Rekonvensi untuk seluruhnya Dalam Konvensi dan Rekonvensi: - Menghukum Pemohon Kasasi untuk membayar biaya perkara dalam tingkat kasasi ditetapkan sebesar Rp500.000,00 (lima ratus ribu rupiah);