136/Pdt.Sus-PHI/2019/PN.Bdg.

Putusan PN BANDUNG Nomor 136/Pdt.Sus-PHI/2019/PN.Bdg.

Case Information

Court: PN Bandung

Classification: Perdata Khusus

Verdict date: 21 August 2019

Court Officials

Main Judge: WASPIN SIMBOLAN, S.H., M.H.;

Judges: ATMARI, SH., MH.; SRI WAHYUNI, SH.;

Clerk: R. YANCE RAHADYAN S, SE, SH.;

Parties / Pihak

Plaintiffs / Applicants (1)

Filing or appealing side

Plaintiff (1)

CECEP AMIRUDIN

Defendants / Respondents (1)

Responding side

Defendant (1)

PT. DADA INDONESIA

Rukan Avenue No. 8-176 Jakarta Garden City

Also in 11 other cases

1077 K/Pdt.Sus-PHI/2019 (2 December 2019) — Mahkamah Agung

Decision / Putusan

MENGADILI DALAM PROVISI - Menolak tuntutan provisi Para Penggugat seluruhnya ; DALAM POKOK PERKARA 1. Mengabulkan gugatan Para Penggugat untuk sebagian; 2. Menyatakan putus hubungan kerja antara Para Penggugat dengan Tergugat sejak 31 Oktober 2018 dengan kualifikasi PHK karena perusahaan tutup akibat rugi selama 2 (dua) tahun berturut-turut; 3. Menghukum Tergugat untuk membayar kekurangan upah tahun 2018, kekurangan THR 2018, penggantian uang makan bulan Januari sampai dengan Desember 2017 dan bulan Januari sampai dengan Oktober 2018 serta kompensasi PHK kepada Para Penggugat yang seluruhnya berjumlah Rp.15.408.436.025,- (lima belas milyar empat ratus delapan juta empat ratus tiga puluh enam ribu dua puluh lima rupiah) dengan rincian sebagai berikut : No. Nama Kekurangan Kekurangan Penggantian uang Uang Pesangon, Jumlah Urut Pekerja Upah 2018 THR 2018 Makan 2017 -2018 UPMK & UPH Seluruhnya 1 CECEP AMIRUDIN 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 63.399.351 72.925.901 2 AAN DARLIAH 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 75.286.729 84.813.279 3 AAN DARWATI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 75.286.729 84.813.279 4 ADE IMAS 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 75.286.729 84.813.279 5 AEP SAEPUDIN 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 51.511.973 61.038.523 6 AGUS AWALUDIN 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 47.549.513 57.076.063 7 AGUS KOSASIH 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 47.549.513 57.076.063 8 AHMAD SUFLAN 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 55.474.432 65.000.982 9 AHMAD TUBAN SALOKA 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 39.624.594 49.151.144 10 AI NURYANI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 51.511.973 61.038.523 11 AI TUTI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 63.399.351 72.925.901 12 AMIRTA SETIA 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 43.587.054 53.113.604 13 ANAH ROHANAH 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 63.399.351 72.925.901 14 ANDAYANI SOMANTRI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 63.399.351 72.925.901 15 ANI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 63.399.351 72.925.901 16 ANNISA 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 51.511.973 61.038.523 17 ANTON SEPTIAN 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 47.549.513 57.076.063 18 ARIS SETIAWAN 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 63.399.351 72.925.901 19 AYU ROHAYU 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 51.511.973 61.038.523 20 BADRU ZAMAN 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 51.511.973 61.038.523 21 BURHANUDIN 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 67.361.810 76.888.360 22 CUCU MARYAM 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 43.587.054 53.113.604 23 CUCU SUSILAWATI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 39.624.594 49.151.144 24 CUMARIAH 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 75.286.729 84.813.279 25 DADAN RAMDANI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 47.549.513 57.076.063 26 DADANG 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 51.511.973 61.038.523 27 DADANG RUSTIAWAN 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 63.399.351 72.925.901 28 DADI MULYADI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 63.399.351 72.925.901 29 DEDE KOMALASARI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 59.436.892 68.963.442 30 DEDE RUSMINAH 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 67.361.810 76.888.360 31 DEDE SUHARNI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 67.361.810 76.888.360 32 DEDE SUMARNI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 55.474.432 65.000.982 33 DEDE TRISNAWATI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 43.587.054 53.113.604 34 DEDEH HALIMAH 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 43.587.054 53.113.604 35 DEDEH KURNIA 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 63.399.351 72.925.901 36 DEDI SETIAWAN 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 75.286.729 84.813.279 37 DEMI ANITA 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 67.361.810 76.888.360 38 DESI SUGIARINI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 63.399.351 72.925.901 39 DEWI HABEAHAN 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 39.624.594 49.151.144 40 DIDI DARMAN 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 51.511.973 61.038.523 41 DINI FEBRIYANTO 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 47.549.513 57.076.063 42 EKA KARTIKANINGSIH 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 51.511.973 61.038.523 43 ELIH FUJI ASTUTI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 67.361.810 76.888.360 44 ELIH MARLIAH 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 47.549.513 57.076.063 45 ELIN HERLINA 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 27.737.216 37.263.766 46 ELVA MARDIYAH 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 63.399.351 72.925.901 47 ENCUM 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 55.474.432 65.000.982 48 ENCUN KURNIA 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 51.511.973 61.038.523 49 ENI MULYANI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 63.399.351 72.925.901 50 ENI SUHENI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 67.361.810 76.888.360 51 ENI SULASTIANINGSIH 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 47.549.513 57.076.063 52 ENI WAHYUNINGSIH 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 51.511.973 61.038.523 53 ENO SOLEHA 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 75.286.729 84.813.279 54 ENTIN 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 63.399.351 72.925.901 55 ENUNG 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 63.399.351 72.925.901 56 ENUNG SITI KOMARIAH 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 67.361.810 76.888.360 57 EPA KOMALA 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 27.737.216 37.263.766 58 ERNAWATI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 51.511.973 61.038.523 59 ERWIN HERWIANA 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 51.511.973 61.038.523 60 EVA PUSPITASARI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 75.286.729 84.813.279 61 FARID PERMANA 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 47.549.513 57.076.063 62 GALIH RIMA MUSTIKA PUTRI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 51.511.973 61.038.523 63 HAMDAN SULAEMAN 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 43.587.054 53.113.604 64 HANA NOVITASARI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 51.511.973 61.038.523 65 HENDRA SUTISNA 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 63.399.351 72.925.901 66 HENDRIK HERYANTO 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 59.436.892 68.963.442 67 HERLAN SETIAWAN 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 51.511.973 61.038.523 68 HERLINITA 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 51.511.973 61.038.523 69 HERYATI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 63.399.351 72.925.901 70 HETI SUNARNI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 59.436.892 68.963.442 71 IJAH HODIJAH 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 51.511.973 61.038.523 72 IKA KARTIKA 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 55.474.432 65.000.982 73 ILA ANA LESWANTI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 51.511.973 61.038.523 74 IMAS MASITOH 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 59.436.892 68.963.442 75 IMAS SULAEHA 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 27.737.216 37.263.766 76 INDRI WULANDARI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 47.549.513 57.076.063 77 INOK KOMALASARI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 63.399.351 72.925.901 78 INTAN NURLAELASARI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 51.511.973 61.038.523 79 IRA ARFANI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 59.436.892 68.963.442 80 IRAENI YAOMI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 51.511.973 61.038.523 81 IRWAN 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 51.511.973 61.038.523 82 JAELANI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 51.511.973 61.038.523 83 JAJANG NURYAMAN 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 47.549.513 57.076.063 84 JAMILAH 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 31.699.675 41.226.225 85 JOKO SUSANTO 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 67.361.810 76.888.360 86 JUARIAH 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 63.399.351 72.925.901 87 JUJU JULAEHA 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 47.549.513 57.076.063 88 JULAEHA 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 51.511.973 61.038.523 89 JUNAENI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 63.399.351 72.925.901 90 KARNASIH 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 63.399.351 72.925.901 91 KARTINI KURNIASIH 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 63.399.351 72.925.901 92 KASIYATI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 63.399.351 72.925.901 93 KHAIRUL SALEH 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 63.399.351 72.925.901 94 KHANIGIA FITRI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 51.511.973 61.038.523 95 KHUSNIATUN 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 63.399.351 72.925.901 96 LILIS NURYANI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 75.286.729 84.813.279 97 LOLA KAMILAH 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 47.549.513 57.076.063 98 LUKMAN NURHAKIM 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 47.549.513 57.076.063 99 M ROPI NOPANDI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 47.549.513 57.076.063 100 M.MUHIDIN 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 63.399.351 72.925.901 101 MAEMANAH 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 51.511.973 61.038.523 102 MAMAN SUMARNA 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 51.511.973 61.038.523 103 MAMAY MUKTAMAR 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 59.436.892 68.963.442 104 MARIA INDRATI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 55.474.432 65.000.982 105 MARLINA 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 59.436.892 68.963.442 106 MARLINA 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 63.399.351 72.925.901 107 MARTINUS MURIN 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 51.511.973 61.038.523 108 MARYANI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 63.399.351 72.925.901 109 MARYANI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 59.436.892 68.963.442 110 MELISA MELAWATI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 47.549.513 57.076.063 111 MIMIN AMINAH 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 51.511.973 61.038.523 112 MIRAYANI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 11.887.378 21.413.928 113 MISTATI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 51.511.973 61.038.523 114 MOCHAMAD IKHSAN 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 59.436.892 68.963.442 115 MUHAMAD JUHDAN 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 59.436.892 68.963.442 116 M TAMRIN 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 67.361.810 76.888.360 117 MULYANAH 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 63.399.351 72.925.901 118 MULYATIN 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 27.737.216 37.263.766 119 MUMUH MUKAROMAH 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 51.511.973 61.038.523 120 MURNI NURHAYATI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 63.399.351 72.925.901 121 NANI SUPRIYATI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 51.511.973 61.038.523 122 NANIK HERAWATI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 63.399.351 72.925.901 123 NENENG HABIBAH 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 43.587.054 53.113.604 124 NENENG LILI HERMAWATI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 47.549.513 57.076.063 125 NENENG RINA RAHMAN 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 63.399.351 72.925.901 126 NENG SOLIHAH 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 51.511.973 61.038.523 127 NENTI LUSMAYANTI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 55.474.432 65.000.982 128 NIA HARTATI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 43.587.054 53.113.604 129 NIA KURNIA 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 59.436.892 68.963.442 130 NINA KRISNA 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 75.286.729 84.813.279 131 NITA PITASARI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 47.549.513 57.076.063 132 NONENG NURMANSYAH 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 43.587.054 53.113.604 133 NONO NURODIN 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 51.511.973 61.038.523 134 NOVI MARLIANTI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 39.624.594 49.151.144 135 NOVIA ARISTIN ANGGRAINI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 51.511.973 61.038.523 136 NURBAETI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 51.511.973 61.038.523 137 NURHALIMAH 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 55.474.432 65.000.982 138 NURHAYATI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 27.737.216 37.263.766 139 NURJANAH 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 51.511.973 61.038.523 140 NURKIMAH 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 67.361.810 76.888.360 141 NURMALASARI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 47.549.513 57.076.063 142 NURUL ANWARIAH 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 63.399.351 72.925.901 143 NYAI NURHAYATI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 67.361.810 76.888.360 144 PAMUJIYANTO 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 55.474.432 65.000.982 145 PARJIYEM 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 63.399.351 72.925.901 146 PIPIT PUSPITASARI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 47.549.513 57.076.063 147 PURWANTO 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 67.361.810 76.888.360 148 RAJIO 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 75.286.729 84.813.279 149 RANI INDRIANI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 55.474.432 65.000.982 150 RATNAWATI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 55.474.432 65.000.982 151 RATNINGSIH 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 51.511.973 61.038.523 152 RIFANI ANZASARI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 47.549.513 57.076.063 153 RIKAWATI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 51.511.973 61.038.523 154 RIKI RAMA HIDAYAT 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 47.549.513 57.076.063 155 RINA HANDAYANI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 51.511.973 61.038.523 156 RINA NURHIKMAH 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 51.511.973 61.038.523 157 ROBIAH ADAWIAH 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 63.399.351 72.925.901 158 RUKMANA 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 47.549.513 57.076.063 159 RUPIJEM 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 51.511.973 61.038.523 160 SAKDIYAH 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 47.549.513 57.076.063 161 SANTI SARI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 39.624.594 49.151.144 162 SEFTI MELIYA UMMINISA 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 31.699.675 41.226.225 163 SHERLY MELINDA 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 27.737.216 37.263.766 164 SINTA RIANI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 47.549.513 57.076.063 165 SITI AISAH 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 55.474.432 65.000.982 166 SITI FATIMAH 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 47.549.513 57.076.063 167 SITI HARISAH 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 67.361.810 76.888.360 168 SITI IRMAYANTI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 51.511.973 61.038.523 169 SITI KURNIA 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 63.399.351 72.925.901 170 SITI ROHAENI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 39.624.594 49.151.144 171 SRI IMBARWATI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 75.286.729 84.813.279 172 SRI RAHAYU 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 51.511.973 61.038.523 173 SRI SULASTRI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 43.587.054 53.113.604 174 SRI YOEGIANTI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 63.399.351 72.925.901 175 SUGENG WIDODO 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 75.286.729 84.813.279 176 SUHENDI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 51.511.973 61.038.523 177 SUMARSIH ROMAYANI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 67.361.810 76.888.360 178 SUNARTO 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 75.286.729 84.813.279 179 SUNARYA 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 63.399.351 72.925.901 180 SUPRAHATI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 59.436.892 68.963.442 181 SURYADI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 47.549.513 57.076.063 182 SUSANTI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 51.511.973 61.038.523 183 SUSI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 43.587.054 53.113.604 184 SUSI HERAWATI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 59.436.892 68.963.442 185 SUSI ISNAWATI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 43.587.054 53.113.604 186 SUSI NURFITRIYANI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 51.511.973 61.038.523 187 SUSI SULASTRI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 51.511.973 61.038.523 188 TATI MULYANI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 63.399.351 72.925.901 189 TATI SULASTRI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 51.511.973 61.038.523 190 TITI SITI HALIMAH 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 39.624.594 49.151.144 191 TOMI SUBARA 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 63.399.351 72.925.901 192 TRI WARSIH 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 31.699.675 41.226.225 193 UJANG MARNA 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 47.549.513 57.076.063 194 UMAY WIARSAH 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 59.436.892 68.963.442 195 UPIT PUSPARINI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 43.587.054 53.113.604 196 WAHIDIN 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 59.436.892 68.963.442 197 WANTI PURNAMASARI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 55.474.432 65.000.982 198 WARTA WIJAYA 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 51.511.973 61.038.523 199 WAWAN HERMAWAN 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 39.624.594 49.151.144 200 WAWAN KUSTIAWAN 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 75.286.729 84.813.279 201 WINANENGSIH 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 63.399.351 72.925.901 202 WIWI FATIMAH 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 51.511.973 61.038.523 203 YANI MARYANI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 51.511.973 61.038.523 204 YANI MULYANI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 55.474.432 65.000.982 205 YANTI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 67.361.810 76.888.360 206 YANTI RUSMIYANTI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 67.361.810 76.888.360 207 YANTO MARYANTO 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 59.436.892 68.963.442 208 YATI SUMIATI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 59.436.892 68.963.442 209 YATNA 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 51.511.973 61.038.523 210 YAYA SUNARYA 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 55.474.432 65.000.982 211 YAYAN YANA P 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 75.286.729 84.813.279 212 YAYAT 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 67.361.810 76.888.360 213 YAYAT 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 43.587.054 53.113.604 214 YENI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 63.399.351 72.925.901 215 YENI HELSI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 51.511.973 61.038.523 216 YENI PERLINA 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 63.399.351 72.925.901 217 YOYOH ROKAYAH 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 31.699.675 41.226.225 218 YUDAWATI RATNINGSIH 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 67.361.810 76.888.360 219 YUNUS FIRMANSYAH 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 39.624.594 49.151.144 220 YUYUM KUSMIATI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 75.286.729 84.813.279 221 ZAENAL ABIDIN 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 75.286.729 84.813.279 222 JALALLUDIN 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 51.511.973 61.038.523 223 CECE MAMAN 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 51.511.973 61.038.523 224 TISNA 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 47.549.513 57.076.063 225 POPON 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 63.399.351 72.925.901 226 FITRI SOPIAH 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 47.549.513 57.076.063 227 ARSIAH 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 55.474.432 65.000.982 228 SUSILAWATI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 51.511.973 61.038.523 229 RITUN 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 59.436.892 68.963.442 230 ZAILANI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 51.511.973 61.038.523 231 SUGENG 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 59.436.892 68.963.442 232 TASDI TRIYANA 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 51.511.973 61.038.523 233 DADAN NURJAMAN 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 43.587.054 53.113.604 234 DIAN ANDRIAN 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 47.549.513 57.076.063 235 EMI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 67.361.810 76.888.360 236 MARFUAH 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 63.399.351 72.925.901 237 FINA AGISTA PUTRI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 39.624.594 49.151.144 238 DEDE RISMAWAN 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 47.549.513 57.076.063 239 MOCH AHMAD ASHARI 6.770.500 677.050 2.079.000 47.549.513 57.076.063 4. Menyatakan sah dan berharga sita jaminan (conservatoir beslaag) atas barang-barang bergerak milik Tergugat yang telah diletakkan dalam perkara ini sesuai Berita Acara Sita Jaminan Nomor 136/Pdt.Sus-PHI/2019/PN Bdg, tanggal 19 Agustus 2019; 5. Menolak gugatan Para Penggugat selain dan selebihnya; 6. Membebankan biaya perkara kepada Tergugat sejumlah Rp 77.048.000,00 (tujuh puluh tujuh juta empat puluh delapan ribu rupiah)